Enterprise Library Sometimes Chops XML into 2033 Characters

This morning I began what I thought would be an uneventful task in .NET: connect to one database, download as XML some rows from a table that have changed since a given time, then pass that XML to a stored procedure in another database so that the changes can be merged. Just two tables: one relatively small, the other just a 2-column relationship table for the first table. Here’s a contrived snippet to serve the same purpose:

The SQL:

CREATE PROCEDURE dbo.GetXmlValue

AS

SELECT TOP 100
*
FROM sys.all_columns
FOR XML AUTO, ROOT('Root')

The Code:

Database db = GetDatabase();

DataSet set;

using (DbCommand cmd = db.GetStoredProcCommand("dbo.GetXmlValue"))
{
set = db.ExecuteDataSet(cmd);
}

In my application, it was this second table that tripped me a bit. The first only had a few changed rows, so the XML was only 500-1000 characters. The second table generated a much longer XML string – 3864 characters long. My initial plan was to return two tables, each 1 column and 1 row. When using Database.ExecuteDataSet to fetch the results, however, the second table yielded two rows. I backtracked, second guessed myself, and even grabbed a couple of guys in the hall to double check my code. No one could explain it. It seemed odd that this hasn’t come up before for someone here. I did a bit of Googling and only found a couple of results. This Microsoft Knowledgebase Article just says it’s “by design” and to use SQLCommand.ExecuteXmlReader.

The next question that came up was “Well, what does it do if I return a long XML value among other values in the same row?” I tested this out and everything worked as expected. All of the XML was in a single column value as it should be.

I still can’t exactly explain it. ExecuteScalar has a character limit of 2033 characters. I suspect that because each table in my result set is just a single column value, something somewhere is relying on ExecuteScalar.

My solution? In my stored procedure I just stored each of my table results as an XML typed variable, then returned the two together in the same row.